Sunday, September 6, 2015

Authors Helping Authors: 15 Writers Move onto Round 2

As part of the Kickstarter campaign for my new Riyria novel, Death of Dulgath, I promised to include the short story of an aspiring (or new) writer at the back of the book. While the writer will be compensated at twice the standard rate, ($0.15 a word (up to 5,000 words) as opposed to the standard SFWA rate of $0.06), the real purpose was to provide exposure for the writer in a crowded literary landscape, and hopefully jumpstart their career.

I've received hundreds of entries. If you’re wondering if I staffed this out…no, I read each one personally. It should be understood I didn’t read any of them completely.

In the same way that it is possible to tell if a person is a skilled pianist or a novice from only a few bars of music, most people can tell the difference between a skilled writer and a novice from a few sentences. I most often read until I hit enough problems to determine the entry wasn’t going to make it. This usually required me to read no more than the first page, often only the first paragraph. In a few cases only the first sentence was needed. And in two cases only four words. If I read beyond the first page, the piece was dropped into the “promising” folder to be read in full later. If not it went into the “reject” folder.

This is similar to how publishers and agents deal with large piles of submissions and is something of which all professional writers should be aware. You don’t have long to make a good impression. The good news—if you want to call it that—is that unlike most agents and publishers, I skipped the query letter and read the story. I didn’t care who you were or what your credential were until I determined if you could write. Only after your story landed in the “promising” folder, did I read the query, or even your name.

For those who are wondering why they bothered to work on the query if I ignored it in the majority of the cases, don't should be worth your time. You see,  everyone who submitted will walk away with at least a critique of their query, but that process will occur once I'm past the deadline for delivering the novel.

Judging literature is a subjective endeavor. I do not profess to being The Authority on Good Writing, but this contest isn’t being award to the best literature submitted, it’s going to the one I like best. While most creative competitions are determined by a consensus of opinion, in this case (because this is my competition) only one opinion matters—mine. As a result I can tell you exactly how I judged this first round. I eliminated entries if they exhibited any of the following:

  1. Poor writing (repeated words, unnecessary words, poor word choices).
  2. Story doesn't start at the start of the piece.
  3. Too much exposition.
  4. Difficult  to understand.
  5. Lack of interest.
Any of these were likely to send your story to the “reject” folder very quickly. I would however read more if I encountered: 
  1. An original or interesting premise.
  2. Excellent writing.
Two pieces I read in their entirety because they were so well written, but alas, both lacked a story—part of the reason why I kept reading is that I was trying to find it. There are many short fiction works that aren’t stories, meaning they don’t pose a question then answer it. Instead they are simply an example of writing that begins nowhere special and ends at a random point with out actually having one. I don’t view these as stories so much as exercises in writing. While they might display superb literary skills, they’re cheating by skipping the hardest part: developing a complete, satisfying, engaging and hopefully, moving story in less than 7,500 words. This is what makes short story writing so hard. You have to invest massive cosmic power in an itty-bitty living space, something Hemingway famously managed in six words: 

For Sale: Baby shoes, never worn. 

Works that skip this part usually display only the skill, or acquired craft, of a writer, but there is more to fiction than craft. As a result, excellent writing got my attention, however, it didn’t win me over. A great story with wonderful characters and mediocre writing consistently beat out great writing with only the hint of a story.
Of the hundreds of entries I went through, fifteen are waiting for me in the “promising” folder. Those of you who entered this contest and don’t see your name on the list, might wonder what exactly you did wrong, or—should you find your name listed—what is it you did right? Here are the most common problems I found:

  1. You started your story with boatloads of exposition. As in: In the land of Hezgoroth a hot wind blew across the land where ancient kings of the Jeilian Horde warred against the*…I’d usually hit reject at this point. I don’t want you to tell me a story. I want to live it. (* This is not from a submission. I made this up. I won’t post anyone’s work and criticize it. That’s just mean.) Fact is, I hate the rampant habit of the fantasy genre to indulge in excessive, and usually unnecessary, exposition. If your story started this way, have hope, not everyone almost no one feels the way I do.
  2. Nothing happens at the start of the story, as in: Leroy sat on the log pondering his life as he waited to find out the verdict the king would hand down. Ever since he left his home of… Again this is exposition, but at least it started with a character doing something, too bad they were only sitting. Better to have started the story with the verdict, or better yet with the consequences of the verdict. (Again, this isn’t from a submitted story.)
  3. Purposeful avoidance of details that keep the reader from understanding anything, as in: The person was there thinking. They weren’t certain when it would happen, but they knew it would happen soon, or soon enough. It was hard to tell. Or it’s slightly lesser annoying sibling, dithering, as in: He wasn’t certain but he seemed to be almost falling. He thought he might be, and maybe he was but… 
  4. You may have spent your precious first words of your story setting the stage as opposed to starting the story, as in: The forest was dark and gloomy. A thick eerie mist rose. A full moon was only a hazy faint light. Everything was cold and damp and filled with fear full forbidding. It was an evil night. Even the…Reject. 
  5. Confusion. If I couldn’t understand what was going on, I passed. 
  6. Boredom. Maybe I could understand it, and something was going on, but if I wasn’t intrigued, I passed. 
A short story is akin to a sprint. The faster you are off the blocks the better your chances of winning. Meandering your opening isn’t going to win races. Remember the first sentence, and to a lesser extent the first paragraph, might be all anyone ever reads and this applies to novels too. The opening has to be great. 

That said, if the first sentence was a bait-and-switch where you invented a compelling opening line just for the sake of a great opening line, that too was passed on, as in: Bob was plummeting to certain death. Bob woke from his dream drenched in sweat. Bob was born thirty-five years about, and now I will tell you about his childhood. It started… 

The opening also can’t just be action—as many of them were. Action scenes didn’t work for me. Combat isn’t interesting. It’s actually very boring unless you care about those involved, and you can’t if you don’t know who they are.

In the first paragraph of your story I was looking to discover who the story was about (not just their name), what they were trying to do, and why they were having troubles doing it. The entries that managed this had a much better chance of me getting to the end of the first page. Therefore a sentence like: Officer Jane Williams didn’t know whether to cut the blue or the red wire, but she knew she had ten seconds to decide.
  • Who: Most likely a police woman. 
  •  Situation: Most likely defusing a bomb. 
  •  Problems: A bad decision will bring death.
After the first sentence I am into this story, (which again I just made up). I don’t need setup, or mood, exposition, backstory, fancy prose, or clever internal dialog. Twenty-three words and I have what could be the entire story laid out along with the main character and the conflict. As the reader of this I know all the important facts, and am invested. I want to know if she cuts the right wire, what happens if she doesn’t. This is where this story might end as the question posed in this opening is which wire should she cut? The story then could be how she goes about deciding which wire. This could even have a twist in that she cuts neither wire. The point is, a short story, being short, needs to start right at the beginning, grab the reader and go. At least, that’s what I’m looking for. And the ones who managed this, or at least managed to entertain me and were also well written, and who didn’t blow it by the end of the first page, got into the “promising” folder.

Out of hundreds there were fifteen. They are (in no particular order): 
  • Jillian Lokere
  • H. L. Fullerton
  • Kate Smoot
  • Hannah Dancy
  • Tyler Powell
  • Desmond Warzel
  • Thorn Stratton
  • N. E. White
  • Heather Jean Matheson
  • Steve Williamson
  • Marina Lobstetter
  • Terence Kuch
  • Anthony Lowe
  • Setsu Uzume
  • Zachary Brennan
Congratulations to the Promising Fifteen. At this point I will be reading each of these in their entirety and sending the very best to a “Finals” folder. After that I’ll likely invite my wife to read them for a second opinion, then I’ll be contacting the winner. Good luck all.


  1. Dear Mr. Sullivan (Hi Michael?),

    What a fantastic idea to include a short story by a new writer! I particularly liked your break down of rejection reasons in this blog entry.
    Congratulations to the fifteen people in the second round.

    All the best,


  2. YES!! Way to go, everyone!

    Michael & Robin -- Thank you so much for creating this opportunity. It's generous of you to break down the process here on your blog. What a great project.

  3. Here we go Jobschat is Latest Jobs in 2017-2018 India's Day to day Jobs portal

    Jobs Chat is one of the biggest Indian Job Site so here you will getState wise PSC Jobs 2017-2018so

  4. Hi Please tell me the all required information to join Indian Army. I want to join Indian army. So plesae tell me How To Join Indian Army?

  5. Nice blog post you shared with us, thanks for sharing such a valuable post with us, Assignment Writing in UAE

  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

  7. authors and writers are helping all the students for the production of the quality of the work. The ability of the man to use more item is done for the humans. The injunction is done for the approval of the needed items for the humans I the same identification of the course work.

  8. authors are introduced to all the contents and fluctuations for the marked opinions. The concepts of the site are introduced for the candidates. The method is ensured for the standardized opinions for the conditioned environments for the lovers.


  9. flipkart emi,
    flipkart debit card emi,
    flipkart emi for debit card,
    flipkart emi on debit card,
    flipkart emi with debit card,
    flipkart emi sbi debit card,
    flipkart no emi cost,
    flipkart emi,
    flipkart with emi,
    flipkart email id,
    flipkart emi mobile,
    flipkart emi without credit card,
    flipkart mobile emi on debit card,
    flipkart emi options,
    flipkart emi card,
    flipkart emi using debit card,
    flipkart emi bajaj finserv
    zestmoney flipkart emi,
    flipkart emi laptop,
    flipkart emi process,
    flipkart emi phone,
    flipkart no cost emi laptops,
    flipkart emi in debit card,
    flipkart emi debit card icici,
    flipkart emi on credit card,
    flipkart emi credit card,
    flipkart emi policy,
    flipkart emi rules,
    flipkart emi cancellation,
    flipkart 0 emi,
    flipkart emi eligibility check,
    flipkart easy emi on debit card,
    flipkart zero emi,
    flipkart emi procedure,
    flipkart emi pay,
    flipkart emi eligibility check sms,
    flipkart emi calculator,
    flipkart emi customer care number,
    flipkart emi process debit card,,
    flipkart give emi on debit card,
    flipkart emi sms,
    flipkart emi icici debit card,,
    flipkart no emi cost ,
    flipkart emi app,
    flipkart emi shopping,
    flipkart no cost emi led tv,
    flipkart easy emi option,
    flipkart emi loan,
    flipkart emi for mobile,
    flipkart emi service,
    flipkart emi with credit card,
    flipkart in emi,
    flipkart debit card emi laptop,
    flipkart cardless emi link,
    flipkart free emi,
    flipkart emi hdfc,
    flipkart emi credit,,
    flipkart emi hdfc debit card,
    flipkart emi message,
    flipkart emi information,
    flipkart emi contact number,
    flipkart emi msg,
    flipkart new emi scheme,
    flipkart emi on debit card hdfc,
    flipkart emi number,
    flipkart debit card emi kaise kare,
    flipkart emi on debit card axis bank,
    flipkart emi registration,
    flipkart emi on icici debit card,
    flipkart emi on debit card quora,
    flipkart emi on axis debit card,
    flipkart debit card emi eligibility icici,
    flipkart debit card emi yes bank,
    flipkart emi on debit card sms,
    flipkart emi bank list,
    flipkart emi process in hindi,
    flipkart emi return policy
    flipkart debit card emi youtube,
    flipkart pay later emi,
    flipkart hdfc emi offer,
    flipkart emi how to pay,
    flipkart hdfc debit card emi eligibility,
    flipkart debit card emi eligibility sbi,
    flipkart debit card emi 2018,
    flipkart emi sbi,
    flipkart emi conditions,
    flipkart emi review,
    flipkart emi payment date,
    flipkart emi helpline number,
    flipkart emi how it works,
    flipkart se emi kaise kare,
    flipkart emi quora,
    flipkart debit card emi quora,
    flipkart emi faq,
    flipkart emi interest rate,
    flipkart emi 60000,,
    flipkart emi without interest,
    flipkart no cost emi quora


  10. authors are helpful for the formation of the brass band and other items for the comfort of the people. It has been challenged and read this in the ambit of the regulation. The constitution of the matter is vital for the flow of the offers for the humans in this ambit and quick succession for the people.

  11. I think, school the board ought to oversee voyages through recorded spots for the understudies to spread consideration among the understudies. These sorts of activities from the relationship of schools are remarkable that assistance the vivacious understudies to get care about history.

  12. I attempted fantastically well to discover this kind of article related with the instructive of incapacitation individuals. You have coursed a stunning article about the direction of crippling individuals and you ought to make progressively like this.

  13. Want to watch live tv on your Android smartphone then download Solid streamz for free. Solid streamz provides access to thousands of channels which you can stream anywhere anytime.

  14. Get Education News University News

    Private Jobs Expereinced and Fresher Private Jobs

    Latest Bank Jobs Bank Jobs

    Latest AP Employement News Employment Jobs

    Latest Railway Jobs Get Latets Railway Jobs

    Latest Walk-ins Jobs Get Walk-ins Jobs

  15. Latest Internship Jobs Updates Jobs portal Fresher Internship Jobs Updates

    Part time Jobs Contract jobs Latest Railway Jobs

    All Latest Railway Jobs over India Best Jobs Portal All India Metros and Railways Jobs Portal

    Daily Current Affairs Updates States and Central Indians Jobs No 1 Site Latest Current Affairs

    Get All the Latest Jobs Updates Indians Jobs No 1 Site All Latest India Jobs Portal

  16. best website for cashback offers in limeroad and other shopping sitescashback on dresses

    best website for cashback offers in shein and other shopping siteslatest offers on fashion dresses

    best website for cashback offers in shop clues and other shopping sitesdiscounts on kichin

  17. tgjobsnews is the best job websiteLatest Central Govt Jobs

    tgjobsnews is India's best job websiteAll central Govt Jobs

    tgjobsnews contains latest job updatesTelangana state Govt Jobs

  18. You define your thought classically by this blog, thank you so much for sharing such an amazing blog. Get website designing services by ogen infosystem in delhi, india.
    SEO Service in Delhi

  19. A web portal ukinfo for Uttarkhand. Know about Uttarkhand and it's heritage.


  20. flipkart fashion sale,
    flipkart fashion sale 70 off,
    flipkart fashion sale 2018,
    flipkart fashion sale gowns,
    flipkart fashion sale kurtis,
    flipkart fashion sale ad girl,
    flipkart fashion sale date,
    flipkart fashion sale tops,
    flipkart fashion sale shoes,
    flipkart fashion sale 2017,
    flipkart summer sale 2018,
    flipkart summer sale,
    flipkart summer sale offers,
    flipkart summer sale 2018,
    flipkart summer sale,
    flipkart summer internship 2018,
    flipkart summer internship 2019,
    flipkart summer collection

    flipkart freedom sale 2018,
    flipkart the freedom sale,
    flipkart big freedom sale 2018,
    flipkart freedom sale 2018 dates,
    flipkart big freedom sale 2018 date,
    flipkart freedom sale offer,
    freedom sale in flipkart,
    flipkart freedom sale 2017,
    flipkart freedom sale 2019,
    flipkart freedom sale date,
    best deals on flipkart freedom sale,
    flipkart the big freedom sale 2018,
    flipkart the big freedom sale 2017,
    flipkart next freedom sale,
    flipkart big freedom sale 2018 offers,
    flipkart freedom sale hdfc offer,
    flipkart great freedom sale,
    what is flipkart freedom sale
    flipkart big billion day offers,
    flipkart big shopping days,
    flipkart big shopping days sale,
    flipkart big shopping days 2018,
    flipkart big shopping days offers,
    flipkart big shopping days sale 2018,
    flipkart next big shopping days,
    big shopping days in flipkart,
    flipkart online shopping big billion day,
    flipkart big apple shopping day,
    flipkart big shopping days 2017,
    flipkart big shopping days terms and conditions,
    flipkart big shopping days sbi offer,
    flipkart big shopping days hdfc offer,
    flipkart big shopping days mobiles,
    flipkart big shopping days 2018 redmi note 5 pro,
    flipkart big shopping days 2018 offers,
    flipkart big shopping days date,
    flipkart big shopping days hdfc,
    flipkart big shopping days oppo f7,
    flipkart big billion day online shopping,
    big app shopping days in flipkart,
    flipkart big shopping days 2016,
    flipkart big shopping days 2017 sbi offer,
    flipkart big shopping days july 2018,
    flipkart big shopping days may,
    flipkart big shopping days may 2018

  21. amazon Cashback offers on Mobiles Cashback Coupons 2018
    amazon Cashback offers on laptops Bank offers 2018
    amazon HDFC bank Offer Instant Cashback offer
    amazon State Bank bank Offer Hot Deals
    Flipkart Cashback offer Today Best Deals

  22. Carrier Job Alert is one best Indias Job Website Latest Central Govt jobs 2018

    India Top Most Jos Portal All Central Govt jobs

    Free Job alert site in India Best Job Website State Govt jobs 2018

    Best State Govt Jobs Site All Latest States Govt jobs 2018

    All Free Upcoming State Govt Jobs Alerts Jobs 2018 General Knowedge and Current Affairs Updates

    BPO and IT Jobs best Indias Job Website Latest ITI jobs and Diploma jobs

    Latest Internship Jobs Updates Jobs portal Fresher Internship Jobs Updates

  23. tgjobsnews is the best job websiteLatest Central Govt Jobs

    tgjobsnews is India's best job websiteAll central Govt Jobs

    tgjobsnews contains latest job updatesTelangana state Govt Jobs

    tgjobsnews contains latest govt job updatesAndhraPradesh Govt Jobs

    tgjobsnews is the best job website for govt jobsBank Jobs

    tgjobsnews is the best job website for all govt jobsRailway Jobs

    tgjobsnews is India's top most job website Central Govt Jobs

    tgjobsnews is one of the India's top most job website All India Govt Jobs

    tgjobsnews is the top most job websiteAll India Central Govt Jobs

    Best Govt Job WebsiteTg Jobs News

  24. Thank you so much for this amazing information sharing with us. Visit OGEN Infosystem for the best Web Designing Company in Delhi, India.
    PPC Company in Delhi

  25. This comment has been removed by the author.


  26. Fever patrol Thermometer device to keep your family safe and protected.Buy it now on cheapest price.

    Fever Patrol Thermometer Review

  27. FitTrack Body BMI Scale have created a few health and fitness products to use alongside their easy-to-use app.Buy it now on cheapest price and get 50% Off.

    FitTrack BMI Scale

  28. Mobile Klean UV Sanitizer is an ultraviolet light sanitizer, which uses a flash of ultraviolet light to eliminate virtually all bacteria and viruses.Buy Now and Get 50% Off.

    Mobile Klean Sanitizer

  29. Muama Enence is a portable translator device that can translate into more than 40 languages in real time. Buy now and get 50% Off.Hurry Up!

    Mauma Enence Translator

  30. CleaniX UV Sanitizer is a sanitizing device. Buy now and get 50% Off.

    Cleanix UV Sanitizer Review


  31. WildSurvive Pro is a survival kit that claims to contain all of the tools needed for outdoor survival.Buy now on cheapest price and get 60% Off.

    Wildsurvive Pro Outdoor Kit

  32. This is a really great article, thank you for sharing this valuable piece of content with us, I will pray for you to get more revenue to this content thank you. You and your reader may also like to read about article of SnoreStop Plus Review!

  33. Nice Post, thanks for sharing such type of valuable content. Kailo Nanotech Patch Review

  34. Thanks,for such a good information provide us. It’s hard to
    find good quality writing like yours these days.
    I seriously appreciate people like you!
    EasyWax OFF Reviews

  35. thanks for sharing such use article with all of us. it is hard to find such good quality content
    Solar PV Design Services
    Residential Solar permit plans

  36. Bhartiwale is a website which helps people to Join Indian Army. Know the latest news from the army regarding Indian army salary, admit card, results, rally news, question papers all are covered in our website bhartiwale.

    Indian Army Bharti | Recruitment post wise


  37. Excellent post. I was looking for some inspirations to decorate my pooja room this year for the grand celebration of Ganesh Chaturthi.
    ANd finally I found a bunch of ideas from your post. Flowers and peacock are the things I liked the most here. Thanks for highlighting so many ideas.

    Happy Valentine Day Wishes in Marathi for Friends
    Happy Valentine Day Wishes in Tamil for Boyfriend
    Valentine Day SMS Wishes in Telugu


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.