Thursday, June 19, 2014

First Five Pages Update


Back in January, I posted that I would read and critique the first five pages of your story. If you’re among the many who submitted and did not receive a reply, I need to apologize. Turns out I’ve critiqued many of the stories sent to me, but none were ever sent out.

You see I had a system. I wrote the critiques and left them for my wife to review and then mail. Why? Because she was concerned—and rightly so—that I might be too harsh or blunt in my comments. When it comes to writing I’ve lost much of my sensativity in the same way I suppose some doctors can become insensitive to the emotional impact of their treatment. I focus on the problem more than the person. I’ve learned not to let comments about my writing harm me emotionally, but this is a skill most aspiring writers don’t have yet. Robin checking to see if I was being an ass seemed like a good idea. Problem was that she became very busy with more important matters and never got around to the Five Pages Project. I didn’t know this until a few of you resubmitted stories I’d already thought I’d done.

So here’s the deal. I’m just going to mail these out ‘as is’ and will continue to do so. This means they’ll be ‘blunt’. Try not to hate me.

You all should keep this in mind: I am not trying to help you be better writers. I’m not trying to teach you to write. I can’t do that. No one can. Only you can teach yourself how to write to the best of your ability. What I will do is explain how I think you should write, which is exactly what any instructor will do. Most teachers base their comments on the foundation of an education they received (which may or may not be of any practical value) but which they believe in because it was what they were taught.

I wasn’t taught anything. Everything I know about creative writing I discovered for myself. As a result, I have a very specific, and admittedly, narrow view of what constitutes good writing. Many works that society admires I don’t care for. I recognize that this is based on my opinion and personal taste, and you should too, because that is what you will receive if you submit your work for my review. In other words, if I trash your wonderful story, remember it’s just the opinion of one guy. And if I’m harsh, or sound uncaring, also remember, I wouldn’t be taking the time to do this if I wasn’t trying to help. Still, it is up to you to decide what advice is worth listening to, and this is another skill you’ll need to develop if you’re to become a successful author, because you’ll be getting a lot of it.

Also, since I started doing this I can see that I’m actually averaging one critique a week (not ten a month.) And by the way, if you send more than five pages, I’ll just be reviewing the first five.

As for what I’ve read so far…

A lot of the submissions are average—what I would expect from new writers. Almost all of you suffer from the same basic mistakes: excessive telling instead of showing, excessive exposition, explanation syndrome, trying to be too artsy, trying to demonstrate your vocabulary, wordiness, setting-the-stage syndrome, dull beginnings, action-packed but confusing beginnings, keeping too much from the reader, telling the reader everything…and so on.

The first five pages are hard, so are my critiques.

And again, sorry for the delays, many of you will be getting responses soon. If not, resubmit.

44 comments:

  1. It's cool that you would even do this. I've heard many writers who have "made it" indicate a need to "give back" in some way or another, which sounds awesome to me now, and hopefully still will when I've "made it". Did this offer have a cut-off date?

    ReplyDelete
  2. No cut off date. No guarantee either. I've received many more submissions than I can comfortably respond to. So I tend to pick one at random each week and critique it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Rats...looks like I missed this notification when you started this project, Michael!

    It is pretty awesome of you to take the time to offer some insights to new writers--and honestly blunt critiques now can be a huge help later.

    Just one more reason that you're one of my favorite authors, Michael!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm getting philological education. And i dont like writing! at all. I like learning languages and reading books. But not writing. And what is the most interesting - my parents are writers. When i was to write comparative essay - it was like a torture. And nobody wanted to help me. Nowadays i've learned to do it almost good.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Our team is working 24x7 to offering you the best assistance and help to enhance your gardes. Want to check dissertation editor rate then turn to Students Assignment Help experts faster and get answer to all your questions.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Amazing article written.
    I am an avid reader of your articles.
    Great writing skills shown.
    Checkout my piece of work what is ytmp3?
    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete

  7. Hi! I love your article! I'm usually read New-York
    (https://www.nytimes.com/) . Now i'm gonna read your articles to!

    ReplyDelete
  8. very good writes. feel good after reading this. I really like this. Thank you for this blog post.
    website design company in delhi
    seo company in faridabad
    san jose seo

    ReplyDelete
  9. SBP Automotive - we are copper washer manufacturer, aluminium washers manufacturer, Gaskets & Shims with qua;ity work.
    sbp auto
    aluminium washers manufacturer

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. You can Get Printer Solution 24x7 Canon Technical Support Phone Number +(1)-888-846-5560, if you are confronting any hassles with your printer. You can reach out to Get Printer solution to fix the glitches.
    canon printer technical support phone number

    ReplyDelete
  12. SEO has become today the need of the hour as without SEO it is next to impossible to get the desired ranking on the Search Engine Result Pages (SERPs). If you are looking for the Best SEO Company in Faridbad, don’t go beyond Jeewangarg.com. We have a fully fledged Professional & Experienced SEO Team.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Wanna know my secret technique of writing a term paper? Follow this link https://samedaypaper.org/blog/term-paper-writing and don't tell anyone:)

    ReplyDelete
  14. BIOAYURVEDA brings to you the full spectrum of the best of Ayurveda with organic ingredients and zero synthetics in vegan and vegetarian option. Offered as a holistic ecosystem across the categories of Supplements, Skin+Soin, and Superfoods, these address diverse daily needs of our wellness and wellbeing, naturally.

    blog

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. BIOAYURVEDA is committed to conscious and creative living wherein the uniqueness of each can be explored, expressed and engaged toward creating a more enriched world

    We envision all to be living with the fullness of health, energy and purpose furthering collective calm, creativity and culture.

    Inspired from Mother Nature and curated from the legendary heritage of AYURVEDA, our products foster a nourishing ecosystem enabling these vital principles in us, propelling each one to:

    BE YOU
    As we EXPLORE who we are and stay true to that;

    BE PRESENT
    As we EXIST in peaceful presence, enabling our skills and strengths to serve;

    BE ALL
    As we ENGAGE with creation to be in blissful blossoming of all that we can be.

    best anti aging moisturizer
    best anti aging night cream
    best anti aging products
    best anti wrinkle eye cream
    best ayurvedic hair oil for hair growth
    best face cream
    best face wash
    best face wash for acne
    best face wash for acne prone skin
    best face wash for oily skin

    ReplyDelete
  17. I like the way you share the information.Thanks for such amazing information.I really appreciate your effort.
    Online Pharmacy Store

    ReplyDelete
  18. iphone display replacement

    This is the right web site for everyone who wants to find out about this topic. You know a whole lot its almost tough to argue with you (not that I really would want to…HaHa). You certainly put a brand new spin on a subject which has been written about for a long time. Wonderful stuff, just excellent!

    samsung display replacement
    Aw, this was an exceptionally nice post. Taking a few minutes and actual effort to generate a really good article… but what can I say… I hesitate a lot and never manage to get anything done.

    microsoft display replacement
    I’m impressed, I have to admit. Rarely do I come across a blog that’s both equally educative and interesting, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. The issue is something that not enough folks are speaking intelligently about. I'm very happy that I came across this in my search for something regarding this.

    oneplus display replacement
    Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thank you so much, However I am having problems with your RSS. I don’t understand the reason why I cannot subscribe to it. Is there anyone else getting identical RSS issues? Anyone that knows the answer will you kindly respond? Thanks!!

    samsung laptop service bangalore

    lenovo laptop service bangalore

    An outstanding share! I have just forwarded this onto a co-worker who was doing a little research on this. And he actually bought me dinner due to the fact that I found it for him... lol. So let me reword this.... Thanks for the meal!! But yeah, thanks for spending the time to discuss this topic here on your web site.

    hp laptop service bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  19. Really amazing content, thanks for sharing with us and keep updating! This website article is really excellent and unique. I will visit your site again. You can see the Bangladesh Education, Events, JSC, PSC, SSC, HSC, Honours, nu, Result, routine and Job circular Pureinfobd

    ReplyDelete
  20. Mortgage in Brampton
    motrgage in Toronto
    We work with Canada's premium financial institutions to offer you the best mortgages in the market and the lowest interest rates. Names such as Royal Bank, Scotia Bank, Bank of Montreal, TD Canada Trust, CIBC, National Bank, and more, guarantee the best service and highest savings for you.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thanks for Sharing your article... Keep it up You can buy Lenalidomide Online in Indian Pharmacy
    lenalidomide cost
    lenalid 25 mg
    lenalid
    lenalid 5 mg
    lenalid 15 mg

    ReplyDelete
  22. Hello, My name is Jay Miller, and I was search articles, Amazing post and Keep Sharing
    hepcinat 400
    sofovir
    myhep
    sovihep
    resof
    buy sofosbuvir
    sovaldi generic

    ReplyDelete
  23. To be honest I found very helpful information your blog thanks for providing us such blog
    Cricket Player

    ReplyDelete
  24. Amazing post and Keep Sharing your article my social media Platform...
    Shiva Food Packaging assured the quality of biodegradable, paper, glass,areca-leaf material corn starch and bakery product material and best services of product and provide doorstep delivery to customers with lowest price and minimum transport on every order

    ReplyDelete
  25. Деревянные окна из цельноламельной лиственницы в доме из дерева В дом были сделаны и поставлены окна из лиственницы со стеклопакетами. Брус: трехслойный клееный, цельноламельная лиственница, сорт АЕ. Отделка: покрытия на водной основе «RENNER Aquaris», Италия. Цвет отделки - Махагон. Стеклопакеты: двухкамерные энергосберегающие с низкоэмиссионым И-стеклом. На большом глухом окне выполнена расстекловка бруском толщиной 50 мм. Окна под крышей на 3 этаже имеют фальшпереплеты внутри стеклопакета толщиной 18 мм. Читать еще

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thank you for reading my profile with love. I am Baani a City Escort and Welcome to the tropical country, blessed by God and magnificent in nature. When you will meet to City Escort Baani Your search will be finished then. I describe myself as a young white lady of 21 years. I am a beautiful hot tigress with beautiful curves. I am a lovely sexy City Call Girl. I am of a smiling and friendly nature I am a good living who appreciates the meetings which take place in good humor and bursts of laughter. Make me laugh and I will be conquered. I am the ideal host to show you around the most exclusive places in the city. Exciting and extremely attentive in the type of fun that likes to party with City Escort Service. I like meeting new people and socializing is my specialty. Effortless Sexy and undeniably elegant I love the pleasure of being an elite escort in City as well as the excitement of doing sexy fashion sessions as a model. With this beautiful model on your arms, you will be the envy of every man in the room.
    Bhagalpur Escorts !!
    Patna Escorts !!
    Gaya Escorts !!
    Gwalior Escorts !!
    Ratlam Escorts !!
    Indore Escorts !!
    Bhopal Escorts !!
    Ujjain Escorts !!
    Satna Escorts !!

    ReplyDelete



  27. Hello, your blog is more informational for me thanks for sharing such type of content really.
    It is a very helpful and knowledge worthy content like us and we provide
    Latest news of India in hindi to our curious readers.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.